What Is Money, Anyway? Commodity Edition

Fiat money is even more elastic than credit money because governments can create or destroy it at will for very little cost. This tremendous elasticity, however, means governments can cause inflation if they issue more fiat money than the current price level requires. In other words, unlike commodity and representative monies, fiat money is not self-equilibrating. A central bank or other monetary authority must decide how much to circulate at any given time. Monetary authorities choose wisely at times, but other times they do not, either as an honest mistake or quite purposefully. In some regions, such as New England and the Carolinas, the bills depreciated significantly and there was a hike in commodity prices as the bills lost value. During wars, countries turn to fiat currencies to preserve the value of precious metals such as gold and silver.

• In other words, I would need to find a mechanic who would be willing to exchange car repairs for a private bassoon concert by 9 AM tomorrow so I can drive to my next orchestra rehearsal.
• Similarly, corn has been used as money throughout Europe from the time of the Ancient Greeks right up to the period of the industrial revolution.
• Most early money systems were based upon a commodity, or valuable good.
• You would need to load up a truckful of items the grocer might accept in exchange for groceries.
• Some advantages of commodity money are like the raw form of the commodity can be redesigned into commodity money, the government never controls the commodity money, etc.

This chart depicts changes in the price level in the United States between 1865 and 1900, when the country’s unit of account was defined in gold. The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, a children’s book by Frank Baum made legendary by a movie version starring Judy Garland as protagonist Dorothy, is an allegory depicting the major political divisions of the era. Oz is of course the abbreviation for ounce; the yellow brick road refers to the gold standard; the Emerald City symbolizes Greenbacks; and in the book, Dorothy’s slippers were silver, not ruby, as they were depicted in the movie. Representative is a type of money that is issued by the government and backed by commodities such as precious metals like gold or silver. The value of this type of money is directly linked to the value of the asset that is backing the money. The value of fiat money is determined by supply and demand, and it was created as a substitute for commodity money and representational money in the early 20th century. Representative money is a type of money that is issued by the government and backed by commodities such as precious metals like gold or silver. AssetsLiabilities+ $1000 deposit + $1000 checkable deposits – $900 excess reserves+ $900 loan + $900 deposit + $900 checkable deposits All in all, $1900 is traveling around in circulation, having started with only $1000 in fiat money. The additional $900 has been generated as debt by the bank and reflects commercial bank money.

Stages of Evolution of Money

Another problem with the barter system is that it does not allow us to easily enter into future contracts for the purchase of many goods and services. For example, if the goods are perishable it may be difficult to exchange them today for other goods in the future. Imagine a farmer wanting to buy a tractor in six months using a fresh crop of strawberries harvested today. Because the strawberries won’t last, such a transaction is unlikely to occur.

This is why Bitcoin will never serve as a currency for major economies and why virtually every country in the world has moved away from the gold standard and why they will never return. Before the development of a medium of exchange—that is, money—people would barter to obtain the goods and services they needed. Two individuals, each possessing some goods the other wanted, would enter into an agreement to trade. For instance, in addition to being commodity money, cigarettes can be smoked, while gold and silver can be used for making pieces of jewelry. The Gold Standard was the predominant monetary system in the west for the 50 years from 1870 to 1920, a system where legal tender was convertible into gold coin, and a period of unrivaled economic growth and stability. During World War 2, the Red Cross would deliver food packages to allied prisoners that contained various items including cigarettes. Those cigarettes were more durable and storable than the other items, and not all prisoners were smokers.

Join millions of people in learning anywhere, anytime

These research-based essays offer insight and analysis focused on advancing an economy where all can thrive.

Any CBDC will likely fail with the failure of fiat money, unless it is backed by a valuable commodity. On this page I will focus on the earliest evolution of money from the barter system to various types of commodities that have been used as money. I’ll also ponder some of the frailties of our current monetary system and the possible return to a representative money if the ravages of inflation and debasement irreparably undermine our confidence in fiat money. The main difference between commodity and fiat money is that commodity money has an intrinsic value. In other words, it has a use and value outside of its use as money. For example, gold can can be used in jewellery as well as a money.

commodity money

Fiat money is easily accessible and accepted easily in various ways. On the other hand, Commodity money is accepted in some specific places and it can not be used everywhere. New France, today part of Canada, began issuing paper money in 1685. “It’s not used as money yet, transactionally, very much, because of that short-term volatility in purchasing power,” Edstrom says of Bitcoin. “But, if it reaches its potential over the next decade or two, then it’s likely that the volatility will reduce, and it’s likely that Bitcoin will become used commonly as money in the economy as it matures.” The characteristics of money are durability, portability, divisibility, uniformity, limited supply, and acceptability.

What makes something money is really found in its acceptability, not in whether or not it has intrinsic value or whether or not a government has declared it as such. For example, fiat money tends to be accepted so long as too much of it is not printed too quickly. When that happens, as it did in Russia in the 1990s, people tend to look for other items to serve as money. In the case of Russia, the U.S. dollar became a popular form of money, even though the Russian government still declared the ruble to be its fiat money. Such regulation of the economy is completely impossible if the money supply cannot be regulated. This is why the United States and every other country of the world has left the gold standard and why cryptocurrencies will never be a major currency for any major economy. When the economy contracts, the central bank can lower interest rates and increase the money supply simply by creating more money, then using that money to buy government debt securities, such as US Treasuries in the United States. When the economy is overheating, then the central bank can contract the money supply, which throttles the economy to a safer pace. Bitcoins solve this problem by using a blockchain to create and store the Bitcoins and to record transactions.

Fiat Money

Another disadvantage of cryptocurrencies is that the government does not benefit from seigniorage, the profit from the creation of money, which can be substantial. For instance, in 2021, the United States supply of M2 money was about $20 trillion. If the US increases its money supply by 3% annually, that is an extra $600 billion annually that would otherwise have to be collected from taxes. Investopedia requires writers to use primary sources to support their work. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. We also reference original research from other reputable publishers where appropriate. You can learn more about the standards we follow in producing accurate, unbiased content in oureditorial policy.

Examples of commodities that have been used as mediums of exchange include gold, silver, copper, salt, peppercorns, large stones, decorated belts, shells, alcohol, cigarettes, cannabis, candy, cocoa beans, cowries and barley. These items were sometimes used in a metric of perceived value in conjunction to one another, in various commodity valuation or price system economies. We saw a great example of fiat monies and the ability to control interest rates, money supply, and liquidity with the central bank’s response to the Great Recession in 2008. The ability to control those aspects of the money helped lessen the blow to both the U.S. and global economies. Money, especially types of money that take work to produce, often seems arbitrary to outsiders of that culture. But that work ends up paying for itself many times over, because a standardized and credible medium of exchange and store of value makes all other economic transactions more efficient. The apple farmer doesn’t need to find a specific doctor who wants to buy a ton of apples for his expensive services right now. Currencies were backed by physical commodities such as silver and gold, but fiat money is based on the creditworthiness of the issuing government.

This category of money is the narrowest of the three, and is essentially the money used to buy things and make payments (see the “active money” section below). In the case of the U.S. dollar, for example, this meant that foreign governments were able to take their dollars and exchange them at a specified rate for gold with the U.S. What’s interesting is that, unlike the beaver pelts and dried corn , gold is precious purely because people want it. It is not necessarily useful—you can’t eat gold, and it won’t keep you warm at night, but the majority of people think it is beautiful, and they know others think it is beautiful. Gold, therefore, serves as a physical token of wealth based on people’s perceptions. Commodity money is comprised of physical goods that are used as money because they have intrinsic value, which means that commodity money is useful or valuable to the holder. A few examples of commodity money are silver, gold, salt, copper, tea, peppercorns, shells, and silk. This type of money does not need government regulation or recognition to be used as money.

These “rai stones” or “fei stones” as they were called were circular discs of stone with a hole in the center, and came in various sizes, ranging from a few inches in diameter to over ten feet in diameter. Many of them were at least a couple feet across, and thus weighed hundreds of pounds. The biggest were over ten feet across and weighed several thousands of pounds. So, a long-lasting high stock-to-flow ratio tends to be the best way to measure scarcity for something to be considered money, along with the other attributes on the list above, rather than absolute rarity.

Not really, but here are the pros and cons of commodity money versus fiat money. All of the above were forms of commodity money backed by a physical commodity that had an accepted value by all. Money communicates no worth; there remains no difference; the value is symbolic, whether gold, paper, or electronic. Money actually derives its value from the functions it allows, such as a medium of exchange, storehouses of wealth, or a unit of measurement.
With no cash available to prisoners, cigarettes can serve as a medium of exchange that avoids the need to rely on bartering for direct exchange of items. The difference between fiat money and representative money is that fiat money gets its value from demand and supply. In contrast, the value of representative money depends on the asset’s value it is backed by. The fact that fiat money is not connected to tangible assets, such as a national stockpile of gold or silver, means that it is susceptible to depreciation due to inflation. During some of the most severe occurrences of hyperinflation, such as the period after World War II in Hungary, the inflation rate might more than quadruple in a single day. Another important concept to know is that fiat currency is legal tender. Being a legal tender means that it is recognized by law to be used as a payment method.
There are some specific places where we can find commodity money for selling and purchasing. The government does not issue the commodity money, but it is one of the wealth of the country’s economy. Money refers to the source or medium of exchange that can be used to fulfill one’s daily needs. Money is an essential part of every person’s life as without money we can afford anything. Therefore, money has been divided majorly into three types accordingly. But here, we will be distinguishing between fiat money and commodity money. People often tend to get confused between the types of money, but one should be clear and specific about the money as they represent its usage and differences. You’ve probably heard the expression, “Backed by the full faith and credit of the US government,” in reference to the dollar. It gets its value based on the trust people place in the authorities that issue it. Commodity-backed currencies, on the other hand, get their value from the underlying price of the gold, silver, or other materials they’re linked to.

Commodity money is a form of money that has an intrinsic value, meaning it is worth something in its own right rather than simply being a token of financial value such as a banknote. Read more about litecoin calculator here. The best known form is gold or silver coins, though any commodity can fulfill this role. And so it was that the “Swiss” dinar for a period of about 10 years, even without government backing or any law establishing it as legal tender, served as northern Iraq’s fiat money. Economists use the word “fiat,” which in Latin means “let it be done,” to describe money that has no intrinsic value.

American colonies, France, and the Continental Congress started issuing bills of credit that were used to make payments. The provincial governments issued notes that the holders would use to pay taxes to the authorities. The issuing of too many bills of credit generated some controversy due to the dangers of inflation. U.S. President Richard Nixon introduced a law that canceled, the direct convertibility of the U.S. dollar into gold. Currently, most nations use paper-based fiat currencies that only serve as a mode of payment.

If a money is easy to create more of, then any rational economic actor would just go out and create more money for herself, diluting the whole supply of it. In developed countries in particular, people often just hold the currency of that country. In developing countries that tend to have a more recent and extreme history of currency devaluation, people often put more thought into what type of money they hold. They might try to minimize how much cash they hold and keep it in hard assets, or they might hold foreign currency, for example. Third, money serves as a unit of account, which means that it is the ruler by which https://www.beaxy.com/glossary/rekt/ other economic values are measured. If there were no unit of account, the price of every good or service would have to be expressed in terms of the price of every other good and services. Businesses would have to keep track of the value of everything someone might sell in order to be able to decide on a price for their products. Money solves the problem by acting as a common denominator, an accounting method that simplifies thinking about trade-offs. Second, people are willing to sell something for money, even if they have no immediate need to purchase something else, because money serves as a store of value.

In short, each major type of money has some advantages and disadvantages. Monetary systems, like everything else in economic life, are subject to trade-offs. What is best for one society may not be best for another and, indeed, may change over time. Table 3.1 reviews the taxonomy of money discussed in this chapter and the relative merits of different types of money.

Commodity money has intrinsic value because it has other uses besides being a medium of exchange. Fiat money serves only as a medium of exchange, because its use as such is authorized by the government; it has no intrinsic value. As financial assets other than checkable deposits have become more liquid, economists have had to develop broader measures of money that would correspond to economic activity. In the United States, the final arbiter of what is and what is not measured as money is the Federal Reserve System. Because it is difficult to determine what to measure as money, the Fed reports several different measures of money, including M1 and M2. Currency itself is perfectly liquid; you can always change two $5 bills for a $10 bill. Checkable deposits are almost perfectly liquid; you can easily cash a check or visit an ATM. It can be converted to money only by selling it, a time-consuming and costly process. Houses, office buildings, land, works of art, and many other commodities serve as a means of storing wealth and value. Money differs from these other stores of value by being readily exchangeable for other commodities.
Its value can be largely determined by how the issuer’s economy performs. And it allows central banks to have a lot of influence on the economy because they can control the money supply. Since fiat money is not a scarce or fixed resource – like gold – a country’s central bank has greater control over its supply and value. This means that governments can manage the credit supply, liquidity and interest rates more reliably. Commodity money is money that has intrinsic value derived from the commodity from which it is made. This form of money was important in foreign trade, in which representative money tokens tied to the local economy would be worthless to the counterparty. There are numerous examples of commodity money throughout the course of human history, but none has reached the breadth of appeal or significance to the modern financial system as gold. In many countries with a history of high inflation, such as Argentina, Israel, or Russia, prices may be quoted in a different currency, such as the U.S. dollar, because the dollar has more stable value than the local currency.